Siding Repair or Replacement: Which Does Your House Need?

How to look over the damage on your own house and tell whether fixing a few boards or panels will do, or whether it's time to compare it with new siding.

Contractor on a stepladder fitting one long new cream vinyl panel into an older wall of siding, with a box of new panels, offcuts and tin snips on the grass below

Quick Answer

A repair is the better choice when the trouble is confined to one part of the house, any soft wood behind it is limited to that spot, and the new pieces will come close to what's already on your walls. New siding is the stronger choice when cracks, warping or soft boards show up around most of the house. It can also be the better choice when a patch would stand out because your color or profile is no longer easy to get. If your house has a little of both, how many walls are affected and how they'd look afterward are what tip it one way or the other.

Siding Repair vs. Replacement: Three Things to Look At

When Grand Rapids Siding Contractors comes out to a house with damaged siding, the same three things decide whether to repair or replace siding: how far the damage reaches, what's behind it, and whether new pieces will match. You can check the first and third yourself before anyone comes out, and they'll give you a fair idea which way your house is leaning.

How Far the Siding Damage Has Spread

Walk around the whole house and note where the trouble is. Two or three cracked panels near the garage door, a strip the wind unhooked, or a single board that split beside the back steps is damage in one area, and that's repair work. After a windstorm, the damage is often on the walls that faced the wind, while the other sides came through fine. When cracking, warping or soft spots turn up on wall after wall instead of in one corner, new siding is worth pricing alongside the repair.

What's Behind the Damaged Siding

This one can't be judged from the yard. Vinyl can hide water damage behind it, and on painted wood, the clue tends to be paint that won't stay on in one particular spot. If you've noticed a water stain on an inside wall below a window, please include it on the form, because it tells us where to look first. A soft patch of sheathing in one place doesn't mean the whole house needs new siding. That section of wood gets replaced, and the repair carries on from there.

Whether New Siding Will Match

Older vinyl has often faded, and a new panel straight out of the box can stand out against it. Painted wood is more forgiving, because the new board takes the wall's paint color. On a side wall or the back of the house, a close match may be all you need. On the front, where everyone sees it, a color or profile you can't easily get anymore can make new siding the better-looking choice.

Corner of a house where the faded vinyl siding on one wall is cracked and pulling apart along its seams and the siding on the other wall still lies flat, with a downspout and a garden hose between them

What Your Siding Damage Points To

Once you've walked around the house, one of these rows will probably sound a lot like yours.

What you're seeing on the houseWhat it tends to point to
Cracked or loose siding in one or two spotsA repair
A split or soft board under one windowA repair, with the wood behind it checked while it's open
Storm damage on the walls that faced the wind, with the other sides fineA repair to those walls
Cracking, warping or soft boards on nearly every wallNew siding
Patches from over the years that don't match each otherNew siding, for one color on every wall
Damage on the front of the house in a color or profile you can't easily getNew siding, or that wall re-sided from corner to corner
Newer siding installed on top of an older layerNew siding, with the old layers taken off

How the Cost of Siding Repair Compares to New Siding

When you weigh siding repair vs replacement on price, the figures below are what each typically costs around Grand Rapids. The whole-house figures are built on about 1,250 to 2,000 square feet of wall, or 1,500 to 2,000 for wood, and our siding replacement cost guide shows what they include.

Siding repairNew siding on every wall
What it coversA few panels or boardsEvery wall of the house
Typical price around Grand Rapids$300 to $1,500$9,000 to $20,000 in vinyl, $15,000 to $30,000 in fiber cement, $18,000 to $32,500 in wood
The wall behind the sidingLooked at where the siding is openedIn plain view on every wall during the tear-off
How it looks afterwardNew pieces matched as closely as possibleThe same color and style on every side

Here's how that works out on one house. Say the only damage on yours is three cracked panels by the driveway. If the wall behind them is sound, that repair falls in the $300 to $1,500 range. The low end of whole-house vinyl siding, $9,000, is six times the top of that repair range, so for one damaged spot, the repair is the clear value. Now say the cracking and warping show up on three sides of the house, and the earlier patches don't match each other anymore. Repairing every one of those walls is a much bigger job than a few panels, and the patches still won't match. At that point, new siding in the $9,000 to $20,000 range for vinyl tends to give you more for your money, and every wall gets looked at underneath.

A homeowner and a siding contractor hold a cracked piece of gray vinyl siding that came off the back of the house, the opening covered in house wrap behind them

Should I Replace My Siding or Repair It?

If your house is somewhere in between, with damage on a couple of walls and the rest in good shape, that's what the visit is for. We'll look at each wall with you. If you can fix a few siding boards or panels and leave the rest alone, we'll say so, and if it's close, we'll go over both with you.

Not Sure Whether Your Siding Needs a Repair or New Siding?

Fill in the form with what you're seeing and which walls it's on. We'll give you a call to set a day, then come out and go over the house with you.

Get a Free Estimate