# Vinyl vs Fiber Cement vs Wood Siding | Grand Rapids, MI

> Vinyl vs fiber cement vs wood siding on a Grand Rapids, Michigan house: how they compare on looks, upkeep, cold weather and price.

URL: https://grandrapidssidingcontractors.com/guide/vinyl-vs-fiber-cement-vs-wood-siding/

# Vinyl, Fiber Cement or Wood Siding for a Michigan House

How vinyl, fiber cement and wood siding compare on looks, upkeep, winter weather and price, and the kind of house each one suits.

## Quick Answer

Vinyl costs the least of the three to put on, gets its color at the factory and doesn't need repainting. Fiber cement costs more, gives you the look of painted wood boards and is made to resist rot, and it will want fresh paint down the road. Wood sits highest on price, and it's real wood on the walls, painted or stained, with upkeep to match. When you're weighing vinyl vs fiber cement vs wood siding, which one suits your house comes down to the look you'd like, how much painting you're willing to do over the years, and the budget for the job.

## Vinyl vs Fiber Cement vs Wood Siding, Side by Side

Grand Rapids Siding Contractors puts vinyl, fiber cement and wood siding on houses around Grand Rapids, and repairs all three.

| | Vinyl siding | Fiber cement siding | Wood and cedar siding |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| What it is | Molded vinyl panels | Boards and panels of cement, sand and wood fibers, heavier than vinyl | Real wood boards and shingles, cedar among them |
| The look | Lap, Dutch lap, board and batten or shake profiles | Painted wood lap boards, with a crisp shadow line under each one | Real wood grain, under paint or stain |
| Color | Built in at the factory, with no repainting | A factory finish, or primed boards painted once they're up | Paint or stain over the wood |
| Upkeep | A rinse with a hose and a soft brush now and then | A fresh coat of paint down the road, and the caulk at the trim checked | A fresh coat of paint or stain every so often |
| In a Michigan winter | Stiffer in a hard freeze, so a hard knock can crack it | Edges kept clear of roofs and the ground so they aren't sitting in snowmelt | Water that gets into a split can freeze and open it wider |
| Repairs | A damaged panel unhooked and replaced, though faded color is hard to match | A cracked board cut out, replaced and finished to match | Board by board, primed on all sides and finished to match |
| Typical whole-house price around Grand Rapids | $9,000 to $20,000 | $15,000 to $30,000 | $18,000 to $32,500 |

The prices in the table are typical for a whole house around Grand Rapids, built on about 1,250 to 2,000 square feet of wall for vinyl and fiber cement and 1,500 to 2,000 for wood. Our [siding replacement cost guide](https://grandrapidssidingcontractors.com/guide/siding-replacement-cost-michigan/) shows what each price includes and what can raise or lower it.

## Vinyl Siding: The Lowest Price of the Three

**Vinyl's color is made in at the factory, so there's no paint to keep up.** That also means the color you pick is the one the house wears, so it helps to hold samples up outside, next to your roof and trim, before you settle on one.

Vinyl moves with the weather. Each panel hangs loose on its nails so it can grow a little on a hot afternoon and shrink back on a cold morning.

Vinyl suits a house where the budget comes first, where you'd rather never paint the siding, or where you like the profiles it comes in. Some houses mix those profiles, with lap siding on the walls and shakes or board and batten up in the gables.

## Fiber Cement Siding: The Look of Painted Wood

Fiber cement boards are made to resist rot, and from the street they look like painted wood lap siding. That makes fiber cement a good fit when you like the look of painted boards and would rather not keep up a wood siding.

**Fiber cement costs more than vinyl for plain reasons.** The boards cost more to begin with, and they're heavier and take longer to cut and hang, so the labor runs higher too.

**The edges are where fiber cement needs care.** A cut end that stays wet can soak up water and swell, so the boards stop a little above a roof where it meets a wall, sit up off the ground and get a piece of flashing behind each joint. In a Grand Rapids winter, snow sits against the bottom of the walls and meltwater runs off the roofs above them, so keeping those edges dry is a big part of putting fiber cement on a house here.

## Wood and Cedar Siding: Real Wood, With Upkeep to Match

**The trade-off with wood is the finish.** Wood gets painted or stained once it's up, and it needs a fresh coat every so often to stay in good shape. Woodpeckers sometimes go after cedar too, and insects in the wood are one of the reasons they do.

Wood suits an older house that was built in wood, especially one where most of the boards are still sound, and anyone who likes the look enough to keep up with the paint or stain.

## How to Choose the Best Siding for a West Michigan House

### A few questions that help you choose

- How much painting would you like to do over the years?
- What look was the house built with?
- What's the budget for the whole job?
- Is most of the siding on the house now still sound?

**The house itself often points the way.** On an older house built in wood, fiber cement or new wood keeps the look of painted boards. On a newer house that already has vinyl, new vinyl in a color you like can suit it well.

**In a historic district, the city has a say.** In Heritage Hill, Cherry Hill and the city's other historic districts, new siding needs the city's approval before work begins, and vinyl and fiber cement are considered only case by case. On a house there, the wood you have now is where we'd start, and our [wood and cedar siding](https://grandrapidssidingcontractors.com/wood-and-cedar-siding/) page goes over the city's rules.

**If most of your siding is sound, you may not need to choose a material at all.** A few damaged panels or boards can be repaired, and the rest of the wall left as it is, for far less than any whole-house price in the table.

## Comparing Siding Materials: Common Questions

### Which is better, vinyl siding or fiber cement?

It depends on what you want from your siding. If the look of painted boards matters to you, fiber cement can be worth the difference. If keeping the cost and the upkeep down comes first, vinyl is the better fit, and we can price fiber cement vs vinyl for your house so you can compare.

## More on Choosing New Siding

- [What Does Siding Replacement Cost in Grand Rapids?](https://grandrapidssidingcontractors.com/guide/siding-replacement-cost-michigan/)

- [Aluminum Siding: Repair, Paint or Replace?](https://grandrapidssidingcontractors.com/guide/aluminum-siding-repair-paint-or-replace/)

- [Siding Replacement](https://grandrapidssidingcontractors.com/siding-replacement/)

## Weighing Vinyl, Fiber Cement and Wood for Your House?

Tell us what's on your house now and the look you have in mind, and we'll come out, measure the walls and price the materials you're deciding between, in writing.
